Writer in court over 'one mistake one thousand yuan' pledge
0 Comment(s)
Print
E-mail China Plus, August 12, 2017
A Chinese writer is facing a bill of over 172 thousand yuan (almost US$ 26,000) after making a promise five years ago to pay a thousand yuan for every mistake found in his book, reports Beijing News.
Zhang Yiyi published his book in February, 2012. A month later, he posted on the Weibo social media platform that "anyone who finds a mistake in my book will receive 1001 yuan."
In his post, Zhang said that various media insiders were "witness to his words".
Recently, Bai Ping, a professor of the College of Liberal Arts of Shanxi University, announced that he had found 172 mistakes in Zhang's book, which included factual errors, grammatical mistakes, and wrongly-written or mispronounced characters.
After negotiations broke down, Bai decided to sue the writer for 172,172 yuan.
The case was accepted by a court in Beijing, and received a first hearing on August 10, 2017.
During the session, Zhang's lawyer argued that the reward offered by Zhang had a time limit, albeit "not clearly stated," and suggested that the so-called 172 mistakes were too "subjective," or lacked evidence.
Bai's lawyer said his client would accept a discount of 20 percent, but Zhang's lawyer said only 10,000 yuan reward was on the table.
The two sides failed to reach an agreement in court.
A similar "One mistake, One thousand yuan" dispute occurred in 2010, when Bai Ping spotted 909 errors in a book written by Chinese writer Yan Chongnian, and demanded an 850,000 yuan reward as a result.
The case collapsed after the court decided Yan's words made during an interview were meant as a "joke" rather than as a "promise".
Go to Forum >>0 Comment(s)